Best Pizza in North York (2026)
North York's pizza scene in 2026 is way more interesting than chain delivery. You've got Roman-style thin crust hiding in an industrial park, Persian fusion pies loaded with halal toppings, a 30-year family-run classic that never stopped being great, and Korean green-tea dough going viral on TikTok. We ranked the top 8 pizza spots with prices, what to order, and a walking crawl route.
Quick answer: The best pizza in North York is Dispotino Pizza at 675 Steeprock Dr for their Pepperoni Speciale with whipped ricotta & hot honey ($5–7/slice). For late-night halal pizza, go to Pizza Shab at 3 Byng Ave. For the best value whole pie, head to Frank's Pizzeria at 432 Sheppard Ave W ($11–18).
Know Your North York Pizza Styles
North York isn't just pepperoni-and-cheese territory. Here's a quick guide to the styles you'll find across the neighbourhood:
Top 8 Pizza Spots in North York (2026)
Dispotino Pizza
675 Steeprock Dr, North York (industrial park near Keele & Finch)
$5 – $7 per slice • $13 per sandwich
The ultimate "if you know, you know" spot in North York. Dispotino operates out of an industrial park near Keele & Finch with lunch-only hours (closes at 3 PM) and regularly sells out. The Roman-style thin crust is light, crispy, and topped with genuinely premium ingredients — the whipped ricotta and hot honey on the Pepperoni Speciale is the kind of combination that makes you re-evaluate every pizza you've had before.
Heads up: Weekdays only, 11 AM–3 PM. Arrive by 11:30 to guarantee availability.
Google Maps →
Pizza Shab
3 Byng Ave, North York (Yonge & Finch)
$22 – $26 per 12" pie
For something completely different from the Italian canon. Pizza Shab is a Persian-style pizza institution at Yonge & Finch — thick dough, extremely generous cheese, and halal toppings including Persian sausage and seasoned ground beef that you won't find anywhere else. The Rolling Mix is the one to get: it packs multiple meats and vegetables into every bite. Open until 11:30 PM+, making it the best late-night pizza in North York.
Website →
Frank's Pizzeria
432 Sheppard Ave W, North York (Sheppard & Bathurst)
$11 – $18 per pizza
The neighbourhood heavyweight that's been doing it right for over 30 years. Frank's is proof that consistency beats hype every time. There's nothing trendy here — just a family-run Italian pizzeria turning out perfectly chewy dough, tangy sauce, and generous toppings at prices that make Uber Eats orders feel criminal. The panzerotti is a sleeper hit: oven-baked, golden, and stuffed to bursting. If you grew up in North York, you already know Frank's.
Website →
ZZaVia
1597 Bayview Ave, North York (Leaside)
$6 per Roman slice • $21 per round pie
ZZaVia brings genuine Roman al taglio (cut-to-order square slices) alongside classic Neapolitan round pies — a dual format you rarely see in the GTA. The Roman slices use high-hydration dough fermented for 72 hours, resulting in an airy, impossibly light crust. The Leaside location is sleek and modern, with imported Italian ingredients that justify the slightly higher price point. Perfect for the foodie crowd who wants more than just another slice shop.
Website →
Pizza Maru
Yonge & Finch area, North York
$18 – $26 per pie
The most Instagrammable pizza in North York. Pizza Maru's signature move is their green tea dough — a jade-coloured base that's slightly sweet and earthy, creating a totally unique canvas for Korean-inspired toppings. The Holy Honey Sweet Potato Pizza sounds wild but works beautifully, combining Korean sweet potato, mozzarella, and honey in a flavour profile that Italian purists will hate and everyone else will love. A must-try for anyone bored of traditional toppings.
Google Maps →
North of Brooklyn
Avenue Rd & Fairlawn, Toronto (near North York border)
$5 – $8 per slice
The closest thing to an authentic NYC slice shop near North York. North of Brooklyn at Avenue & Fairlawn is technically just south of the North York border, but it's the spot Redditors specifically name-drop in "best pizza near North York" threads. The Grandma square slice — a thick, crispy-bottomed pan slice with tangy tomato sauce — is the must-order. Big, foldable regular slices are exactly what you want at 2 AM after a night out.
Google Maps →
Pizzeria Libretto
Shops at Don Mills, North York
$18 – $24 per pie
Toronto's most reliable Neapolitan chain has a convenient outpost at the Shops at Don Mills. The wood-fired oven delivers properly charred, puffy-crusted pies with imported Italian ingredients — the Margherita DOC with buffalo mozzarella is the benchmark. Perfect for families shopping at Don Mills who want a sit-down meal that's genuinely good. Their frozen pizza line is also worth grabbing for home — it's surprisingly close to the in-restaurant experience.
Google Maps →
Mark's Pizza
371 Old Kingston Rd, Scarborough
$25 – $30 per pie • $5–6 per slice
Widely considered the gold standard pizza in the entire GTA. Mark's earned TimeOut's National Pizza of the Year 2025 for good reason: their sourdough-style crust has a complexity and chew that most Toronto pizzerias can't match, and toppings like truffle cream and hot honey push it into genuinely creative territory. It's in Scarborough, not North York — but at a 20-minute drive from the 401, it's absolutely worth the trip for anyone serious about pizza.
Website →Best Value Pizza in North York
You don't need to spend $25+ for great pizza in North York. Here's where to get the most for your money:
Best single slice: Dispotino Pizza — $5–7 for Roman-style slices made with premium ingredients. Best quality-to-price ratio in the city.
Best whole pie: Frank's Pizzeria — $11–18 for a full pizza. Thirty years of consistent quality at neighbourhood prices.
Best late-night deal: Pizza Shab — $22–26 for a loaded 12" pie that can feed 2–3 people. Open past 11:30 PM.
The Sheppard-to-Finch Pizza Crawl
Three stops, three completely different pizza styles, one afternoon. This crawl explores the range of North York pizza, from hidden-gem Roman slices to old-school Italian to Persian fusion.
Dispotino Pizza (The Hidden Start)
Arrive: 11:30 AM (they close at 3 PM and sell out early)
Get: One Pepperoni Speciale slice + one Mortadella sandwich to split
The vibe: Industrial park, no signage, pure word-of-mouth. The Roman thin crust sets the bar for everything that follows.
Frank's Pizzeria (The Classic Stop)
Transit: TTC Bus 84 East from Sheppard West Station to Sheppard & Bathurst (~15 min)
Get: A small classic pepperoni or the oven-baked panzerotti to compare dough styles
The vibe: Family-run neighbourhood staple. Thirty years of no-frills quality.
Pizza Shab (The Fusion Finale)
Transit: Subway Line 4 to Yonge-Sheppard, then Line 1 north to Finch (~20 min) or a 5-min Uber
Get: Rolling Mix Pizza — the heavy cheese and Persian sausages are the perfect finale
The vibe: Late-night buzz, open until 11:30 PM+. End with something completely different from where you started.
Timing: 3–4 hours total. Important: Dispotino is weekdays only, so plan this as a long-lunch crawl. For a weekend version, swap Stop 1 for ZZaVia on Bayview — their Roman slices are the best Saturday alternative.
Honourable Mentions
Pi Co. (CF Fairview Mall) — Build-your-own Neapolitan pies, $15–18. Great for picky eaters and families at the mall. Website →
Pizza on Fire (880 Ellesmere Rd, Scarborough) — Fusion toppings like Tandoori Chicken and Smoked Salmon. Reddit users call it a "hidden gem" worth the drive. 4.6★ on Google Maps. Website →
Mamajoun Pizzeria (209 Ellesmere Rd, Scarborough) — Armenian-style lahmajoun meat pies ($7–10). A totally different take on "pizza" that's worth exploring. Website →
Maker Pizza (Avenue Rd) — The critical darling of Toronto food blogs. Sesame crust, creative toppings, Matty Matheson connection. If you're in the midtown area, the Tropic Thunder is still the viral king.
Slowhand Sourdough — Detroit-style pizza with a 72-hour sourdough ferment. The pickle pizza went viral on Joseph DeBenedictis' Toronto Pizza Tour (1.2M YouTube views). Love it or hate it, it's worth trying once.